Free college is not the answer

  • by:
  • Source: The Hill
  • 07/31/2020
A number of Democratic presidential candidates are supporting student debt forgiveness and free tuition at public colleges and universities in the United States. While certainly appealing in their bidding sweepstakes for voters, this is terribly dangerous to the economy. Most fundamentally, our American schools and universities are failing students and businesses who hire their graduates. Many economists like to rely on the alibi that contemporary technological innovations do more to make life fun than enhance productivity, but breakthroughs in renewable energy, artificial intelligence, and the like can offer great potential to accelerate growth.

Those require an army of technically literate workers and managers to effectively exploit, but American secondary school students simply do not do as well as peers abroad in math and science on standardized tests. Fewer than 40 percent of high school graduates are adequately prepared for education after secondary school. With some 70 percent going to a university or college of some kind, it should come as no surprise that the dropout rate is more than 40 percent. Of those students who finish four year programs, about 40 percent lack the critical thinking and problem solving skills traditionally expected by businesses of college graduates.

It is no surprise that Federal Reserve economists estimate 40 percent of recent graduates are in jobs that do not require a college education. Even more damning is that many colleges seem to add little value to student skills, regardless of admissions standards. With so many dropouts and poorly prepared graduates, businesses complain of skill shortages and too many graduates cannot pay off their loans. All of this has worsened because of how the student loan program has worked over the decades. Essentially, 18 year olds have been permitted to borrow large sums to attend college and bet, often with uninformed direction from parents, what programs they can actually finish and will lead to a decent job.

That leaves inexperienced young adults at the tender mercies of all the university admission officers and faculty who often give out advice that serves their institutions. Many colleges have also exploited loan programs by admitting unqualified students into nontechnical liberal arts curriculums that offer little future, jacking up their price tags, and spending the bonanza on light teaching loads and student unions that make college more a Club Med experience than a real education.

I cannot tell you how many times I have heard students were told that a liberal arts education can take a young person any place they want to go. Academicians will cite very successful middle aged humanities graduates who went on to brilliant careers in business consulting and technology sectors. However, these days, American students spend about one third less time in class and studying than back in the 1960s, and the technical requirements of good entry level positions have escalated dramatically.
by is licensed under
© 2013 - 2024 Constitutional Rights PAC, Privacy Policy